City
Please Tell Us Your City

Cars Q&A

Question
My daily run is around 100Kms around delhi. Please guide idica vista new hatch back(with new gear box & common rail engine) or new indigo compact sedan ecs(new common rail engine). which one is better for maintenence,comfort& milage resale point of view. or any other best selection pleae guide my maximum budget is 5.5 lacs only.
By Shamsher Singh 05 May 2010
Answers:

when you various other options like figo, ritz, polo and swift why not have a look at them? between the vista and the CS the CS gives some extra boot space. why not take a test drive of some these cars and then decide

Answer by Sri 05 May 2010

hi...
any person sell your wagon r and zen.my budget is 120000 delhi haryana and punjab kindly contact me.....
my no. is 9813338303

Answer by Ravinder 05 May 2010

Also consider the Fiat Punto for a test drive. I am sure you will not be disappointed. It has a good bootspace and legroom at the back and front. The Milage of Punto Diesel is better than most of the new cars as your daily run is over 100KM this will be an imporant factor for deciding.

Answer by Hari Iyer 05 May 2010

Hi,

Lets get straight to the point.New Indigo cs looks good has good space in the passenger cabin as well as boot.Indico Vista is also spacious.Only diffrence is the engine ....however TATA Dicor engines has proved its worth and is dependable.Indigo e-cs is as good car to buy with 23 kms milage is worth every pei...u may have to shell out 50k more than ur buget

Answer by Prabhu 05 May 2010

As per my knowledge Vista Quadrajet will be better option, cause the Engine of the said car is a Award winning Engine i.e.(1.3L) Itlian Engine, & the same Engine is used by the big manufactures like Maruti, Fait etc, the performance of the said Engine has already been proved as one of best Engine in its segment. The same Engine comes in (Maruti Swift, Ritz, Swift-Dsr.), (Fiat Punto, Fiat Lenia) etc. On the other hand Indigo CS, comes with TDI Engine by Tata itself. Better test drive both cars & feels the difference, but as per my suggestion Vista Quadrajet will be better option as per your Budge.

Answer by Jagjit Singh 05 May 2010
expert
Expert`s comment:

Hi,
In the price range mentioned, for maximum utility,interior spaceadvantage of sedan.The New Indigo ECS would be the right selection.

Answer by Shiva Shankar 05 May 2010

Inigo CS even if with Dicor Engine & better in fuel comsumtion or even with improved version (Indigo e-CS), will never be success in this compititive market cause the Engine after a month or so will create the same problem not dependable in long journey, very noisy, hell lot of vibration, poor after sale, But Vista Quadrajet & Manza changed the entire Image of Tata cars, when I first driven vista Quadrajet, I was really surprised with the performance of the car, its plearsure driving car, even better than Maruti Swift's performance. Blindly go for vista Quadrajet, its rich in comfort & features with low price tag. you will be very pleased & will feel proud owning a car like Vista Quadrajet.

Answer by Jatinder Singh 05 May 2010

Hi

I suggest you for FORD FIGO Diesel variant for effective mileage (20+) and latest arriaval in the market within your budget (On road price at 5.5Lakhs).
Happy motoring
Ravisankar

Answer by M Ravisankar 06 June 2010

I WOULD SAY CHECK WITH FIAT PUNTO ALSO...

ITS MORE COMFORTABLE THAN THE VISTA, AND ITS ALWAYS BETTER THAT ANY DIESELS IN CITY RIDE ALSO THANKS TO THE GEARBOX.. AS U HAVE ALMOST 100KMS JOUNEY EVERY DAY GO FOR PUNTO...

BIG NO FOR THE CS... ITS TATA'S OWN CHILD....

Answer by Sree 06 June 2010

Go for Figo only if u plan to sell the car in 3 years. Tata is a good option. i think you really need to think about the parking space in your garage. indigo is a bit longer. it is a very good car, Indica is higly recommendable for city conditions on the basis of better handling and lesser wt to haul. the diffn in boot space is not that big for indica also good big boot. consider you get the same boot length wise. swift will take time to delives but it`s resale value is good. but there is no much diffn bw swift and indica except in interiors. Punto is also a good option with quite good looks but in your price range it`s not advisable for u`l get top of the mark indica but if u go for punto go for 1.4.

Answer by Sooraj 06 June 2010

hai how are you as per my suggestion i recommend you to buy a tata indigo manza instead of ecs or indica because this car is worth for money and the engine is very good so please mind your self to buy this car. i have also purchased a tata indigo manza 15 days ago and i am satisfied so i suggested to buy this car

Answer by Hitesh Kumar Arora 07 July 2010
Post your answer:
Your answer

Provide Contact Details