City
Please Tell Us Your City

Cars Q&A

Question
I Want to buy a sedan car.which one is better between Swift Dzire & Indigo Manza in respect of millage, cot & maintenance.
By Jugal Kumar Minz 04 April 2010
Answers:

The Manza comes from the company that has not made one proper car until now. Unproven performer. The car looks good, but on paper. The Dzire looks terrible and has got a lovely engine but not quite strapped on properly by Maruti - there is definitely a rattling issue. Please consider other options. The Verna for example has a lot of plus points.

Answer by B S Kumar 04 April 2010

swift is better than manza

Answer by Rateesh B G 04 April 2010

If you shortlisted the two, there is nothing more to choose between them. Drive both and go for the one you like the most.
If budget is not a constraint, go for ford fiesta or hyundai verna.

Answer by Abhijit 04 April 2010

Both the cars selected by u are very good and very much liked by the masses.Dezire has a waiting period of around 2 to 3 months that in itself is enough to prove its success story in today 's world when the indian consumer has 10 other options readily available why would anybody wait if the product was not worth it and that too after paying money.as far as manza"s makers worthiness is concerned 201399 units of tata cars were sold in 2009 i.e third in india and abroad by any indian passenger car manufacterer i dont think 201399 people were fools to waste money on such unproven products,in today's competitive market when you start getting 20 calls a day even if u think of buying a car is it possible to survive without proving your worth.indian customer is very aware even people in villages know of all the options available manza is a very good car and worth buying in its price range test drive both the vehicles and decide according to your needs .no need to get confused by personal misleading views of certain self proclaimed car experts and if u start increasing your budget by 3 lacs just bcos some kumar likes a particular vehicle there is no limit to it.

Answer by Rajiv 04 April 2010
expert
Expert`s comment:

Hi,
Among the two though both are good performing cars, to select one Manza makes a better option on account of higher power, upgraded interiors and stylish outlook.Please check the link below for detailed review on Manza which will certainly help you out regarding the same.
http://www.cartrade.com/reviews/Tata-Manza-111892.html

Answer by Shiva Shankar 04 April 2010

Dear Jugal,
Go ahead and take test rides of Tata Manza, Dzire, Ikon ,Accent and Logan which are the sedans belonbging to entry class sedans. When I took the tyest rides of Ikon, Logan,Accent and Dzire a year back I chose Dzire and I am one fully satisfied customer. When I bought Dzire, Manmza was not there and even if manza was present at that time I wouldn't touch Manza as I have heard that the one thing that Tatas lack is consistency in car making No two tata cars of the same model and batch behaves the same way.
As for the negative comments of Mr. Sachin, a hereo honda splendor owner, I have nothing to say except that there is something really bad about his eyesight. How can he say that Dzire is ugly? Has he seen the photos of 50 ugliest cars in the world?Does Mr. Sachin aware that Dzire is the only car among the entry class sedans that has 2 to 3 months waiting time before one can purchase it? I had to wait 2 and a half months after booking to get this wonderful car. I have been driving thios splendid car for the past one and a half years and I am a fully satisfies customer.

Answer by Vijayakumarpn 04 April 2010

Hi,
Ignore both, go for Fiet Linea, which is a head turning car & very new too..

Both other cars r also ok but Linea will bring a new phase in life that's Grand Luxury definate...

Answer by Swapnil Natu 05 May 2010

I am having a 2009 model Swift Dizre ,, done around 20000Kms, recently my cousin purchased a Tata Manza. But I prefer Dizre because of the reliability of Maruti. I donot think TATA Manza will equal performance to Dizre in a long run and resale is also big minus for TATA.

Answer by Mgvenkateshan 05 May 2010

Hello,
Manza is far better than desire, if confused test ride both thorouly - interiors, space, performance, milage comfort,etc. Choose yourself, I m not fan of any of those but between two my vote goes to manza.

Answer by Vinit L Zaveri 05 May 2010

I think you should go for the Manza. It's interiors, mileage, comfort, boot space, legroom, are all much better than the Dzire. I give my vote to TATA.

Answer by Venkat Ramaswamy 05 May 2010

Waiting for swift doesn't mean its a great car. Its human mentality to follow the herd. That what is happening in swift dezire as was no car in that size to compete.More eevr I don't understand whats so great about dezire that people r ready to wait 3-4 months for it.the exteriors design is average in fact bad, interiors are really average same like swift.There are some maruti fans who want to buy each and every maruti car and sometimes company also plays plot to woo customers by creating false demand and that's what is happening in case of dezire.MANZA infact is a better car in all aspect and great there is also waiting period for MANZA(1 month).MAKE UR DECISION WISELY GUYS.

Answer by Varinder Singh 06 June 2010

With referance to all Dzire lover & owners, I would like to suggest that Pl. take the test-drive of Tata Manza & honestly ask the question to your-self, U will get the right answer, which car is better. As far as durability is concerned, Manza also comes with the same Engine which is installed in Maruri Dzire.

Answer by Jagjit Singh 06 June 2010
Post your answer:
Your answer

Provide Contact Details