Please Tell Us Your City

Cars Q&A

i'm planning on buying a sedan in the range of 5-7 lakhs. I've to choose between swift dzire, tata indigo manza and hyundai accent. which car should I choose based on overall qualities?
By Somnath Majhi 04 April 2010

If you want to be happy avoid the Tata. If you have a lot of time to maintain a broken car, then please buy the Tata. Among the others, you may kindly test drive and see what you like. Good luck, Tata!!

Answer by B S Kumar 04 April 2010

yes bro please do not buy any tata vehicle...accent is a smart car but a lil ols n dzire is newer to acccent...i would have chosen accent over dzire ...if u can shell out lil more bucks get a linea...performance good n looks expensive than it is...

Answer by Prabal 04 April 2010

test drive the vehicles your self .compare the features the price and decide for urself .its your money and you have decide.all the vehicles you have choosen are very good desire being in high demand ,accent old design yet very good car and the manza carries the most advanced features in the price range. decide on comparision and logic .not because somebody else does not like the brand.although he or she does not quote any resons for that.

Answer by Rajiv 04 April 2010
Expert`s comment:

Inthe budget range and options mentioned, Tata Indigo Manza makes a good options for its overall features, reliability,and style.

Answer by Shiva Shankar 04 April 2010

You can consider Mahindra logan also because its ride quality and performance is good .

Answer by Thomas 04 April 2010

Logan is indeed a gud option. Now with the future of Logan clear (Mahindra will continue the production and sales),you should not have any doubts about the service and resale as well.
If u do not wish to go for a Logan then Dezire is the best option but u may have to be in the waiting list.

Answer by V K 04 April 2010

swift dzire would be your best choice among the lot. I am telling this from my own experience of owning and driving the same for the past one year. Before taking the final decision of going in for an entry class sedan, I test drove, Logan,Accent,ikon and dzire and found dzire the best among the lot considering, driving comforts, pickup,looks, on board accessories mileage and boot space. Manza is a recent entry but the reviews i read tell a lot of negative qualities about the car.Accent is a good car but on board options are far lesser than that of dzire. So also ikon. When you buy a car, you will have to consider the service facilities too and in that case maruti offers better options.

Answer by Vijayakumarpn 04 April 2010

Logan may be good option, because now Mahindra has taken complete responsbiliy and reliability and also it is most spacious it its catogary and excellent in performance, mileage, handling etc.

Answer by Vinit L Zaveri 04 April 2010

Dear Brother,Better opt for a swift D'zire,rather than a Tata vehicle.Maruti gives you value for your money and Dzire is a good vehicle from it's stable.You can equally think about Ford
Fiesta/Ikon.If you want to know the true colour of Tata's play the game"surprise yourself"in their website & check the result.They talk something & do something else.Best Wishes.

Answer by Prasannakumar K S 04 April 2010

I happend to check Tata Manza, Cheverlet Cruz, SwiftDzire recently. Many automobile magzines say cruz is excellent, Dzire value for money. But I really liked the Manza. It has muscle, lot of space in front and back, excellant interiors. Its more confortable to drive or chauffer driven. It is more relaxing in back seat.It is more comfortable than cruze.
But the problem comes with TATA service. 90% people say poor service from TATA.
If you can afford service from Carnation or similar ones, the go N buy TATA Manza else the proven Swift Dzire

Answer by Sreenivasa Rao K 04 April 2010

Hi First of all you didn't mentioned the variant i.e. Diesel or Patrol. In both conditions if you want to be satisfied by the investment on a sedan you must buy SWIFT Dzire and say "ALL IS WELL"

Answer by Janeshwar Banshtu 04 April 2010

Simply go for Manza. Using Tata cars for the last 4 years without any problem. No service issue at all.

Answer by Anup 04 April 2010

Try verna Petrol very good car in any accept.

Answer by Jagjit Singh 04 April 2010
Post your answer:
Your answer

Provide Contact Details