City
Please Tell Us Your City

Cars Q&A

Question
Which is Best among Swift VDi and Indica Vista Diesel. Also please let me know about the passenger comfort for long drives in both the cars, maintenance cost and detailed fuel efficiency. Currently I sold my 1997 Daewoo Cielo. M planning to go for hatchback diesel. Shortlisted Swift VDi and Indica Vista. hence need the info. My basic requirements are as follows: 1 PWR steering 2 A/c 3 Good leg room (Both front and rear) 4 Decent Boot 5 performance wise good mileage 6 Powerful
By Talha 01 January 2010
Answers:

swift is the best car in this segment...

Answer by Dheeraj 01 January 2010

Both Swift & Vista have the same fiat engine with minor changes in the tuning.
Boot space of vista is more than Swift.
Swift has better acceleration than vista.
Vista is more value for money
Choice is yours - both good vehicles

Answer by Dipankar 01 January 2010

If you want passenger comform for long drives forget swift and go for Vista as it's more spacious and comfortable. As per perception, maintenance cost of Swift is less than Vista. Regarding fuel efficiency, both of them are relatively same with + or - 1kmpl.

For the parameters mentioned by you, the car which is best is
1. PWR steering - Swift(Electronic PS while Vista has Hydraulic)
2. A/C - Both are equally good.
3. Good leg room - Vista (Miles ahead as swift has cramped rear leg space)
4. Decent boot - Both are nearly same
5. Performance wise good mileage - Swift(Vista has same engine through)
6. Powerful - Swift may be.

Don't go by herd mentality and buy swift. Test drive and decide for yourself.

Answer by Sudhir 01 January 2010

hey
listen , both r good car
u ned comfort , boot space nalll..
thn , yew go 4 a vista....
1more thng , vista's handling is bettr thn swift.....
bse ,both r cars i hve.....
swift rear comfort is not good 4 long drive....
so , choice is urssss.....
cyaa...

Answer by Tushar Chhabra 01 January 2010

Hi!
I would definetely suggest FIAT PUNTO 1.3 Active as the best option for you. The reasons are,
1. It has the same engine which is in vista or swift or ritz
2. Addition to your requirements, it has solid body & high quality paint finish.
3. The service intervel is 15000km against 5000km in swift or vista, which itself is a proof for the confidence on performance.
4. The rear seat (particularly the back rest angle) is the best out of three.
Have a test drive and take ur decision.

Answer by M Ravishankar 01 January 2010
expert
Expert`s comment:

Hi,
Both Swift and Vista satisfy all parameters mentioned. Indica Vista would be a good selection for its overall features and price.If price is not a constraint then Swift VDI would be good selection.

Answer by Shiva Shankar 01 January 2010

sir
The both car or the same engine. But swift is the best than vista in all performance. You can trust the Maruthi's net work and maintenance.

There is another option from Fiat - Punto. You can decide the performance after 50000 Km running.

with best wishes

Answer by Arasu 02 February 2010

sir,i am confused which is best between swift and vista,and also i heard that their is a problem in vista gear shift.pls give your opinion

Answer by Guru 11 November 2011

Hi! I own a punto. Its got the best suspension feels like floating. But if comfort means space for u for then no other thought go straight for vista. Vistas suspension is also good but not comparable to punto. Check out and compare the new swift on these aspects - suspension and space. The old swift is nowhere to the comforts of vista and punto.
Gear shifts in vista is hard but not complainable. Even the old swift gears are not as smooth as the punto.

Mileage of all 3 is all the same depending on how u drive.
price and resale, space conscious -vista
refinement and drive pleasure with comfort for 4-punto
Drive pleasure -swift but lacks a bit of refinement on the old. Not sure about new.

Forget about network, now there are many multi brand services and tatas will be found here n there.
spare availability will not hinder much as all 3 share same engine and punto is going up on sales and fiat is veryl serious this time.

Answer by Sai 11 November 2011
Post your answer:
Your answer

Provide Contact Details

Similar questions:
See All Questions