City
Please Tell Us Your City

Cars Q&A

Question
i am congused between TATA MANZA DIESEL AND MARUTI DEZIRE DESIEL.IS DEZIRE ENGINE PERFORMANCE IS BETTER & LESS NOISY THAN MANZA AND DEZIRE IS MORE DURABLE THAN MANZA.WHICH CAR HAS BETTER RIDE QUALITY BETWEEN TWO.
By VISHAL 01 January 2010
Answers:
expert
Expert`s comment:

Dear Vishal
Please go through our Manza review that we have on our site.
http://www.cartrade.com/reviews/Tata-Manza-111892.html

Answer by Quraish 01 January 2010

Both are crappy cars if running on diesel, even though the same engine in an original Fiat combination is superb. The ride quality on the Manza is bound to be good, since Tata have figured out how to make good suspension systems. Some day, they will figure out how to make the rest of the car, too. Maybe your money will help them develop?

Answer by B S Kumar 01 January 2010

Both engines are same.I feel Manza is more comfort and spacious than Dzire.Resale value,service and reliability Dzire is good.I personnally like Swift and I do not like Dzire.

Answer by Panicker 01 January 2010

As a maruti swift Dzire owner for the past one year I will defenitely vote for Dzire. One thing wrong with the Tata cars are that they are not fully dependable and same models perform differentlY. more over the service netowrk of maruti is far better than that of Tatas.Quality wise Tata cars does not keep constant standards.

Answer by Vijayakumarpn 01 January 2010
expert
Expert`s comment:

Hi,
Among the two Manza has the advantage of modern design and style, higher power output and also improved interiors, ride quality makes it best selection.

Answer by Shiva Shankar 01 January 2010

Since i'm owning Manza for past 2 months i'll definitely vote for Manza only......the very 1st most thing is its Mileage(really it gives 20kmpl with Ac)...2nd is itr riding quality which feels you to give driving pleasure....3rd is that interiors and the boot volume is very good....moreover it has Bluetooth facility which provides you a good coomunication with others during driving also...it also has Driver Information System which Instantly displays the current mileage for driver....the audio system also rocks a lot which comes wid 4 speakers and 2 tweeters.....Moreover the engine sound is like petrol engine and is not noisy....The delivery period is also quite short(I got within 15days)....actually Dzire engine is 2005 Fiat Engine whereas Manza's Engine is 2008 Fiat Upgraded Engine which means that the Efficiency,power should be more when compared with the previous models....Then Dzire is costlier than Manza...The top end model of manza costs around 7.5Lacs only which is fully loaded.....another gr8 advantage is that servicing is for only abt every 20,000Km....My opinion is that pls go for manza since it has lot of advantages....

Answer by Arun 01 January 2010

Tata cars are great. using Indica 2002 model, done 108000 plus kms, still in very good condition, no major maintenance. Manza is a great car more spacious, better features and better power to weight ratio as compared to Dzire. Moreover, the suspension of the Tata cars is really great compared to the other cars. So, Manza is true value for money and a better buy.

Answer by Singh 01 January 2010

DEAR FRIEND,
I'M BUSINESS MAN,BUT I'M A AUTOMOBILE LOVER I WISH TO SPEND MY SPARE TIME IN GATHERING THE DETAILS OF CAR SEGMENTS BY THE WAY I SUGGESS U TO GO FOR MANZA BECAUSE IT IS OF WITH FIAT TECH ENGINE WHICH WAS AWARDED AS A ENGINE OF THE YEAR 2009' AND WITH 90'PS HP WITH HI TECH GEAR BOX WHICH MAKES THE VEHICLE RUN NO JERKING AT LOW SPEEDS SAY 35 KMS/H AT OVERDRIVE(5TH GEAR)RANGE AND TOP SPEED OF 177 KMS/H IN A/C ON POSITION AND ITS SERVICE INTERVEL IS OF 20000 KMS AND ONE MORE THING NO CHANGE FOR GEARBOX OIL,SO I SAY WITHOUT DOUBT MANZA IS 99% BETTER VEHICLE THAN DZIRE.

Answer by RANJEED 09 September 2010
Post your answer:
Your answer

Provide Contact Details