City
Please Tell Us Your City

Cars Q&A

Question
With regard to the "Manza": With about 200 kgs of additional weight as compared to its hatchback cousin, How effectively does it perform in city driving especially with respect to the "swift Desire" which has managed to remain about150 kilos lighter? Also, whats the avg kpl of these two cars? Thank u.
By A Banerjee 11 November 2009
Answers:

Dzire is better in terms of engine refinement and tuining and driving pleasure....mileage is also beter in dzire.....
But in interiors manza scores over dzire bocause of its spacious and a bit upmarket feel in interiors....

Answer by Dheeraj 11 November 2009

Check this site for manza's review from zigwheels
http://www.timesofindia.zigwheels.com/tata-manza

Answer by Dipankar Dutta 11 November 2009

Hi Banerjee- I have a swift dzire - petrol model. Average details are -
(1) with AC - City - 13.5KMPL, Highway - 16.5KMPL
(2) Without AC - City - 14KMPL, Highway - 17.5KMPL

Hope this helps.

Answer by Sanjeev Chopra 11 November 2009

eventhough manza and dzire have same engine , the manza engine (same as fiat linea)is eqiped with VGT which produces 90 bhp over dzire's 75 bhp , so it has a better engine capacity over dzire and it can carry those extra 150 kilos easily

Answer by Shodhan 11 November 2009
expert
Expert`s comment:

Hi,
Mr Shoban has given exact comparision.

Answer by Shiva Shankar 11 November 2009

shodhan,
you said it. More than that VGT turbo delivers an un interruped power in over drive , so it could deliver a good mileage - as tata suggests- 20 kmpl. Its too early to say about the mileage and all...

Answer by GEORGE 11 November 2009
Post your answer:
Your answer

Provide Contact Details