Please Tell Us Your City

Cars Q&A

Hi, I want to go for a car between 3.5 Lakh to 4.5 lakh on road. I am looking to Maruti A Star and Hyundai I 10. and you help me to make the final decision. Also, if there is another car in the same range which you t hink is a good return of money, suggest that as well

By Saurabh Baranwal on Dec 18, 2008


  • Hi Buddy!
    how u doin ?????
    when u have a budget of 3.5 to 4.5 lacks,
    y dont u go for SWIFT DIESEL LDI. This car is now available for around 4.6 lacks.
    Now Fiat Palio diesel is also coming with new ingine and load of new features and cost around 4.16 lacks ex-showroom.
    Go for any of these cars. They are true value for money. All the very Best.Good Luck.
    And these cars also have very low maintainence cost and high average.
    My Personal Choice:- SWIFT DIESEL.
    Answer by Kapil Gandhi on Dec 19, 2008

  • Hi Saurabh,

    I suggest you go for WagonR / Santro Xing as the A-Star & i10 have narrow space inside. If you want good returns & less maintainance then go for WagonR.

    Best of luck.
    Answer by Ravi on Dec 19, 2008

    Answer by Prateek on Dec 19, 2008

  • hi
    Go for Hyundai i10, it is better than Maruti A-star

    Amit Garg
    Answer by Amit Garg on Dec 19, 2008

  • sir ji,
    my advice will help you....
    you have following options...
    (1) santro xing
    (2) hyundia i10
    (3) A star
    (4) Swift Ldi
    (5) wagonR

    i would seriouly recommened you to go for swift Ldi best in performance, nice fuel efficency, low maintanace cost, good after sales service,
    awesum re sale value...and nice comfort....
    Answer by Simran Pal Singh on Dec 20, 2008

  • Try the Fiat Palio. You must try the Palio 1.6, it will come the same price and there is no small car like this in India with its 100bhp engine. You will outgrow a car like A Star, Alto etc in no time, but not a Palio 1.6. You wont feel apolegetic using it after a few years like you certainly would using a small car like A Star.
    Answer by Yusuf on Dec 20, 2008

  • My suggestions are,
    If it is for,
    Milage + Resale value = Swift Ldi
    Milage + Safety = Palio stile SD
    Cost + Safety = Palio stile SL
    Cost + Performace = Santro GL
    Cost = Maruti 800 dx

    Please don't look A Star, WagonR, Zen Estilo or Alto etc
    Answer by M Ravisankar on Dec 20, 2008

  • Hi i have both the cars for u at range call me no 9869851745
    also i have all new cars.
    Answer by Kishor on Dec 20, 2008

  • Expert Hi,
    With the budget and options mentioned you can go for i10 .
    Best alternative would be a Santro GLS
    Answer by Shiva Shankar on Dec 20, 2008

  • One thing that Ravishankar has pointed out that most people ignore is safety. I agree with hi on that points, what 2 km less fuel effient compared to Safety ! Go for a Palio.
    Answer by Yusuf on Dec 20, 2008

Post your Answer


Similar Questions