City
Please Tell Us Your City

Cars Q&A

Question
HI... i'm very much confused with Swift Dzire(Diesel) and Tata Manza(Diesel).. Which would be better based on features, performance, mileage , maintanence , look.... OR shall i go for any other car in this price range?
By Vasanth 11 November 2010
Answers:

best is swift Dzire...perfomance and re sale value is best

Answer by Riyas 11 November 2010

Go for Maruti Swift D'zire it looks nice & performance is better

Answer by Shreedhar 11 November 2010

Dear Vasant,
Go for MANZA coz nice look,interiors are very nice,plenty of boot space,18+ mileage,and best in its class suspension.
Dzire is the most ugly vehicle on the indian road....!
Definately go for MANZA.....!

Answer by Rambha 11 November 2010

Pls go for Swift Dzire Diesel only .

Answer by Biswajit Ghosh 11 November 2010

let me brief you with pros and cons of both cars based on which u can take ur decision

suzuki dzire has a wonderful mileage and great pik up & great resale value. very gud city car for self driving

cons: the car is very light weight and very risky to drive on highways at high speed & has a problem of bubbling while applying brakes, very unstable i wud say. again comfort is not so gud being a maruti vechicle.

talking about manza, its a wonderful product with great interiors as well as some high-tech features available only in luxury cars. extremely powerful, safe and stable on highways.comfort is just superb & mileage is also 18+

cons: the only negative point is resale is not as gud as dzire

so if u r luking for a city car, go for dzire & IF U R INTO lots of travelling, manza is a far better choice

Answer by PULKIT CHAUDHRY 11 November 2010

i agree with Pulkit
Go for TATA MANZA quadrajet AURA ABS BS4..
As compare to Dzire Manza having lots of Advanced features,
dont think anything Chose only TATA Manza

Answer by Prasad Sapkal 11 November 2010

I am agree with Pulkit and Prasad.
From my side I just want to say:
At first please remove maruti from Dzire and Tata from Manza then go to showroom and test drive both the vehicles.
Definitely you will get your answer.
..............That will be Manza.

Answer by Shekhar 11 November 2010

I have owned manza quadrajet for 4 months. Great Engine and great performance. You need to get prepared subpar tata post sales service and poor plastics inside the car.

Thanks

Answer by Csvsunil 11 November 2010

It's laughable when people say dzire is a good lookin car... hey its not even avarage , its the ugliest ........

Answer by Sachin Kachare 11 November 2010

maruti Dezire is always adviceble in many aspects .It have prooved effeciencey in milege performance and having more resale value it is suitable both for city traffic and moderate long journeys ie below 200 km
If u want to travel less than 200 km per day gop for swift dezire

Answer by Dr Satya Prasad 11 November 2010

Hi i would like to give u technical details about both these cars. Manza diesel is 1248cc VGT(variable geometry Turbocharger) producing 90 PS @ 4000 RPM & 200 Nm @ 1750-3000 RPM where as Dzire engine is 1248cc FGT (Fixed Geometry Turbocharger) producing 75PS@4000RPM & 190Nm @2000 RPM. ON pen & paper Manza seems a producing more power and torque but what is the use of these extras? extra torque will be helpful for initial pull and a greater power will help u to reach more speed. Onething to notice in a VGT engine the torque remains constant over a wide range of RPM where as in FGT engine it drops from the peak RPM. SO Technically MANZA is a better option than DZIRE. Other advantages r on cost, Space and a host array of luxury features on MANZA make it a value for money. Lets understand why MANZA being more advanced than DZIRE costs less. 1248cc MULTIJET engine was originally developed by FIAT. FIAT & GM are having joint venture. MARUTI SUZUKI r also having joint venture. 2 yrs before SUZUKI bought 10% stake in GM. So the lisence to produce 1248 cc Multijet diesel engine came to MARUTI in FIAT-->GM-->SUZUKI path. so the royality money is paid many times. For TATA the lisence came from FIAT directly against sharing their Sales & Service network. So it costs less for the more advanced engine on MANZA. The flip side with Manza is aftersales value and more weight. iwould rather suggest u to wait for Manza CS where u will same VGT engine, lesser boot space, lesser price and lesser weight. this will be an ideal package. For more queries write to me at satis.sahu@gmail.com

Answer by Satis Kumar Sahu 11 November 2010

I own Hyundai Verna top modle in Deisel version, hence have taken the test drive of Manza in Deisel version, I found the said car was also pleasure driving car & the interior of Manza was good in comparesion to other Tata cars, overall the car is rich in features, comfort etc, with low Price tag which no other manufactures can provide. I have also test driven Dzire in Deisel version. In my suggestion Manza is better than Dzire, should opt for Manza. Rest its upto U to deside.

Answer by Jagjit Singh 11 November 2010
expert
Expert`s comment:

Hi,
To select one, Manza wold be a better selection for its updatedness,improved engine, power and styling.

Answer by Shiva Shankar 11 November 2010

Hi,

Generally everyone says that take Tata Vehicles only if u r going to use it for maximum Kms within 3 to 4 years as after this period, u will have to pay maximum amount on repairs as one after another always works will be coming & there is no end.

So plan & go with Tata Vehicles.

Else there r very good options like Verna & Lenia..

Answer by Swapnil Natu 11 November 2010

Driving the Mean Machine... to Goa leaving all the Cars behind.. the feeling was really awesome... and at even 160 KMPH it is so calm and stable..That it makes you go mad for it.....May the Almighty god gives it a long life... I must Say SX4 rules the road!!!

Answer by Nikhil 11 November 2010

Manza is the best car.

Answer by Sumesh 11 November 2010

I drive Linea diesel and its awesome car. Little lag in the first gear but zooms in second and above.The torque of 210 lets me drive 10kmph in 3rd gear without any engine sluggishness. So no need to change gear frequently.Car interiors nice an it comes with strong metal body so utmost safety.Manza also has same engine so performance may be some what same except other car parts may be the problem.Tata has niggling issues in all there cars and 75% of Tata car owners are facing some problem or other.service in Tata service station has improved a lot except for appointments u have to wait for few days.coming to dezire, it is a bad design and looks sad on road.the car has just attracted "follow the herd" mentally of people.The car interiors are also old and obsolete So if budget no issue u can go for linea or other wise Manza.

Answer by Varinder Singh 11 November 2010

as per my point of view say no for both the cars, just go for fiat linea base model of diesel version! if really u got quqlity conciousness and aware about mileage.

Answer by Anand 11 November 2010

hy guys as i test drive both the cars that is dzire or manza ... I would say go blindly with manza far better than dzire .. solid and quality of manza is awsome . So people says that tata plastic is baad so neglect them manza interior look like a expensive cars and its powertrain is awsome and swift dzire lacks behing in this segment

Answer by Ankit Owner Of Swift 12 December 2010

PRESENT TIME THE TATA MOTORS HAS BEEN CHANGED & REVOLUETIONED ALL THE RULES AND REGULATIONS FOR PROVIDING MORE COMFORT CONVIENENCE IN SERVICE AND BETTER LEUXRIOUS COMPAIR THEN LOW COST MAINTANANCE AND BETTER EFFECIENCY AND MILEGE ALSO PROVEN IN TATAINDIGO(OLD MODEL) TO LATEST LAUNCHED TATA MANZA WHICH IS A WONDERFUL CAR IN MID SIGMENT AND LOW COST CAR IN ANY FACTOR LIKE POWER AND PRICE ALSO.

Answer by Pradeep Kothari 01 January 2011

Manza is better than Dezire becoz of it's good fuel efficency, good looking & power. It's interior is also very good.

Answer by Jyothykrishnan 06 June 2011
Post your answer:
Your answer

Provide Contact Details