City
Please Tell Us Your City

Cars Q&A

Question
Dear Friends, I am planning to buy a sedan car. I travel every day around 20-30 KM & once in two months around 500 Kms ( Visit to my native place). My budget 5-6 Lacs. I am looking for - Tata indigo eCS, Ford Ikon,Indigo Manza petrol,Swift dezire Petrol& Logan Petrol. So can any one pl suggest whether I should go for petrol or diesel & the car model PLs...
By Muthuvel S 10 October 2010
Answers:

you should go petrol its suitable for you all weather

Answer by Srinivasan 10 October 2010

Go for petrol, no doubt.
Among the ones you have short listed, go for Manza, it's truly value for money.
Accent Executive, would also be a good choice.

Answer by Abhijit 10 October 2010

dear muthuvel!
Ritz - compact but design is not good
indigo- road view is very bad
ford ikon- it's good but low milage
swift dezire- better choice - stalin

Answer by STALIN 10 October 2010
expert
Expert`s comment:

Among the cars you have shortlisted the swift dzire vxi makes the most sense as it has a good list of features at an affordable price.Along with that it has a fuel efficient as well as a powerful 1.2 l petrol engine.And yes maruti's service backup is unmatched so I think it is pretty much the ideal car for your requirements.

Answer by Rohit Bajpai 10 October 2010

Without second thought go for Swift dezire Petrol. It is best in its class, very stable and powerful vechile with very less maintainence required.

Answer by Amandeep Singh 10 October 2010

swift dezire

Answer by Ravi 10 October 2010

i want to sell my skoda octavia diesel(excellent sedan/luxury car with good performance), asking price 3,80,000 2004 regd delhi...if any one interested thn call me at 9910405251

Answer by Dipanshu 10 October 2010

I want to buy a zenlx with cng del reg and its 2004 model with 68k driven, single owner. what would be the best price or its good decision for buying it.

Answer by Vikrant 10 October 2010

Thank U Rohit.

Kindly tell the milage of Dezire petrol

Answer by Muthuvel S 10 October 2010

Thank U Rohit.

Kindly tell the milage of Dezire petrol

Answer by Muthuvel S 10 October 2010

Go for Swift Dezire.

But if I were you, would have wated for Totota Etios Sedan.

Answer by Kapil 10 October 2010

I would recommend Maruti Swift D'zire Petrol/Diesel.Diesel version gives 24 kmpl.Good engine,spacious,economy & afterall Maruti's service backup.Toyota etios also can be considered.

Answer by Prasannakumar KS 10 October 2010

Sir, Dzire diesel don't give 24km/l but at best 21km/L though only in ideal condition in high way. Petrol version will give 15km/l and highway, it will give 17-18 km/L. Using AC, both version will come down at average of 2kms than the non AC mileage.But , overall, within your budget, no doubt petrol version (VXI) will best suit you. Thank you. All the best for your new car.

Answer by Partha 10 October 2010

Close your eyes & go for FIAT Grande Punto. Believe me you will get great driving pleasure with good City & Highway mileage. Easy to drive & park in City atleast better than Dzire. Very good stability on highway.

Answer by Kedar 10 October 2010

INDIGO MANZA is the best choice.

Answer by Sumesh Panicker 10 October 2010

Hi....
(1)As u have to travel 20kms a day, its better to go for diesel. Not only that, u can also increase the frequency of the trips to ur native with much worries.

(2) I'll recommend the Swift Dzire Diesel version or the Hyundai Accent Executive Petrol version(with LPG). Both have reliable vehicles with decent mileage. Hyndai accent has plush interiors with good ride and good value(esp the LPG version), while, Swift is good in handling and has high resale value. Both have decent boot space.

(3) Swift Dzire (diesel) gives around 13.5km/l in City and 18km/l in highway while the petrol version gives 11 km/l in city and 16km/l in highway.

Answer by Abhinav G Pillai 10 October 2010
expert
Expert`s comment:

You can safely expect about 13-14 kmpl in the city and 16-17 kmpl on the highway from the swift dzire.Fuel economy largely depends on your driving style and if you drive with a light foot you can even extract a bit more.Happy Driving.

Answer by Rohit Bajpai 10 October 2010

My personal experience with new vehicle is please take test drive of all the above vehicles. dezire, manza, logan accent and take decision . Any one can give suggession but ultimately u should use the vehicle. so your comfort is the first prefrence. so call all the dealers near you and book test drive and take the decision it is my personal suggession

Answer by Thomas 10 October 2010
expert
Expert`s comment:

Hi,
In the budget range and requirments mentioned, Indigo eCS is a good choice.Advantage are the interior space,utility of sedan and relaibility.

Answer by Shiva Shankar 10 October 2010

Morning Shiva / Rohit & Friends,
Yesterday Ford Ikon reduced theie prize to Rs5.08(EX Show room Prize). You already suggested to buy Indigo ecs or Dezire petrol. Kindly brief the merits & demerits of Ikon and your strong suggestion...

Regards
Muthuvel.S

Answer by Muthuvel S 10 October 2010
expert
Expert`s comment:

The Ford Ikon is a good car no doubt but you should also see that it is a decade old design and hence is not expected to continue for much longer.I would still recommend a maruti swift dzire vxi as it is a newer design and you just can't go wrong with a maruti.

Answer by Rohit Bajpai 10 October 2010
Post your answer:
Your answer

Provide Contact Details